| Sunglasses as the first photo | Photofeeler says anything blocking a clear view of your face needs a retake. In a Reddit thread, a man asked if sunglasses were acceptable in his only good photo. One reply said people assume you are hiding something. | The same spot with the glasses off, in open shade or beside a window. Keep sunglasses to one later photo at most. |
| A dead fish held toward the camera | In an r/Tinder thread a woman asked whether men think these photos help. Replies split: some women swipe right on fishing, others said every third profile has the same shot. | If fishing is part of your life, show you on the water or with the rod, smiling. Do not lead with the catch. |
| Gym mirror selfie | InsideHook calls an unsmiling mirror shot in a muscle tank "meatheady" and suggests a photo of you playing a sport, taken by someone else. A Reddit thread on mirror selfies drew a reply asking why nobody uses the camera timer. | Prop the phone and use the timer, or hand it to a friend while you train or play. |
| A group photo as the first photo | In an r/Tinder thread, one commenter said they swipe left on any profile with more than one group photo. One of Photofeeler's women could not tell which man owned the profile in a group selfie. InsideHook suggests one to three group photos. | Lead with a solo photo. Add one group photo from the fourth slot on, where you are easy to spot. |
| A selfie in the car | One of Photofeeler's three women read a car selfie as hookup-focused, another would swipe left on it as a first photo, and a third wanted him out of the car doing something. | Get out of the car. A photo of you doing the thing you would otherwise sit in the car to get to. |
| Shirtless pictures | InsideHook cites a Dating.com survey from 2020: men with shirtless photos got 25 percent fewer matches, and 66 percent of the women surveyed said such a photo signals a lack of maturity and self-awareness. We have not seen the survey itself. | Leave it out. If you are at a beach or pool, have someone else take it and keep it off the lead slot. |
| Only close crops, no full-length photo | Photofeeler says you always want a full-body photo somewhere, tasteful and intentional. Its women reacted warmly to a full-length travel photo. | One recent full-length photo in daylight, standing naturally, not posed in a mirror. |
| Never smiling | Photofeeler's July 2026 analysis of men's dating photos found an open-mouth smile scored 2.55 points higher on trustworthiness than no smile, a closed-mouth smile 1.86 points higher (1 to 10 scale). It is the company's own data. | A candid smile, for example while you laugh at the friend holding the phone. |